I The 10 year partner route is extremely a tough one to meet. Do you not meet the financial requirement, as the Home Office and COurts are refusing a lot today, unless there is war in her country, and there are reasons of health , political, which will prevent you from joining her. Is that the case ...

Why was it rejected?

Buzz wrote:I received the same letter just yesterday i am confused i do not know how to answer the questions

Did they also ask about exercising treaty rights?

any ideas guys?

Will I be able to take this appeal to upper tribunal in case FTT refuses?

Using Eind and Akrich?

Is circumventing law permissable in eu law.

I really dont understand since i am getting different views.

bump.

Any ideas guys?

If it is refused by FTT tribunal judge will I be able to challenge using errors in law to take case to upper tribunal I.E Eind and Circumventing laws?

What are the chances I can get this case to the Upper tribunal considering Eind and motive not relevent?

Message sent

Obie,

Can i send you a private message?

Expert opinion will be welcome.

So what was the outcome?

Can that circumvention issue be used in future spouse applications?

320 (11)

No dont meet financial requirement at present. Just wondering whether tribunals will simply follow uk legislation rather than eu law which says motive irrelevant. Im lost for words tbh. Rather have stayed in Ireland. Also do you reckon if things dont go well it can be used for refusal of spouse visa...

Ten months in Ireland seems more than reasonable to me. Perhaps you should wait for the outcome of the appeal, which in my view does not appear unmeritorious based on the information you have provided us. She does not need to leave to apply, given that you have a child together. Can they use this 3...

She does not need to leave to apply, given that you have a child together

Thanks Obie.

I dont understand this though.

Not applying entry clearance. And not staying long enough. We stayed 10 months Ah so you did not apply for family permit before entering? Also did you integrate in the eea country not trying to be invasive just wondering what I would have to do if i get sam response as they gave still nto made a de...

Not applying entry clearance.

And not staying long enough. We stayed 10 months

We have now decided to apply for uk spouse visa when my wife leaves uk after failing surinder singh

Just wondering whether being refused for circumventing immigration rules will be a factor when now applying for spouse visa.

Refusal under 320 (11) perhaps

Any ideas?

The following is Denmarks Surinder Singh guidance. Both Eind and O and B recognised. https://www.nyidanmark.dk/en-us/coming_to_dk/familyreunification/family_reunification_under_eu-law/family_reunification_danish_nationals_under_eu-law.htm 5. Economic activity upon return A Danish national who has ex...

We made a joint claim whilst our residence card application via surinder singh was in process which is now refused. I am british and wife is now overstayer/illegal. When we made claim i told them i am british and wife has a eea residence card application in process. Few months later we got a large s...

Experts,

Whats your opinion on the reply i got from eu commission?

i contacted Eu commission Can you reproduce the correspondence from them here? Redact any personal details and either attach the image or (if electronic) copy-and-paste the text. I regret to inform you that I do not share your view that case law of the Court of Justice on rights of EU citizens who ...