The ICO has the ultimate discretion, and allowed your cousin to enter, as s/he was able to do so. The ICO was not obliged to do so. Your cousin was very lucky. It doesn't mean it will apply to anyone else. OP here was unlucky, but the ICO was not wrong. If it depends on luck than why did you say th...

Obie, you keep repeating that his wife is exercising treaty rights, but you don't know that. Does she have a job? Is she self sufficient or a student? You don't know what she is and neither did immigration at the airport! I have read all your previous posts. FYI Upon landing at dublin airport my fi...

@Obie we had a good discussion yesterday. there was idea to submit the sworn Affidavit by EU citizen, but one of the barrister not recommend this.. his point was ATM whatever you will provide they will see them with Fraudulent document lens As they are already not accepting what you provided so bet...

How do you know the clerk had rejected your case ?? Dont you think they were investigating your marriage even after the polish embassy e-mail ?? If they had taken a decision beforehand than they wouldn't give you any temporary permission to reside. Did you find out on what grounds do the polish emba...

An appeal doesnt take months.
If i were you i would change the solicitor.

Were you deported with an entry ban ?

Do you know the reason why your visa was revoked at first?

I dont think your case is affected by the chencholiah judgement. The minister will surely tell your solicitor as to why the polish authority beleive that she was residing in poland. Your solicitor can only do something once they find out the reason as to why the polish authority said this. Are you s...

finalversion_2k wrote: ↑

Mon Jan 06, 2020 2:01 pm

Yes 21 Days time they gave me.. I lost faith on DOJ, like what else document they were expecting??

Was she ever employed in Poland??
Or engaged in any other activity in Poland??

Just to let everyone know that retention applicants who are not impacted by the chenchoolia judgement are getting temporary Visa's for 9 months and when that Visa expires the immigration is giving another temporary 9 months permission to reside until a final decision has been taken. Their excuse of ...

Any update on this?
Has someone recently received any response from the retention unit ??

The judgement does not prevent the minister from removing people, it only prevents him from deporting and imposing bans on entry. Therefore the minister can remove individuals whose family have ceased from exercising treaty rights. This judgement applies if there was a genuine relationship. A frien...

Retention cases are delayed because of the chencholiah judgement. The immigration is sending out letters and this is what the letter says. """ The position in your clients immigration case is that his case is impacted by the ruling of the European court of justice in the chencholiah c...

Straight answer to your question, if you not able to provide her documents it will be very difficult for you, as in first letter they will ask you all her 3 years activities.. Ok thanks. This theory doesnt make any sense at all. How can a Saperated or divorced couple would still provide papers to t...

you get married in 2015 and you said you have stamp4EUFAM from 1 years.. means you get stamp4EUFAM in 2018.. may I ask what was your status from 2015 to 2018?? Also EU citzen is she in ireland?? or left the state?? to retain right you need to fill EU5 below are links and also explanatory guide.. pl...

are you questioning about 2 different peoples/things?? didn't get your question.. when you get married? when divorce proceeding?? Would they apply eu3 or eu4? people apply EU3 after 5 years on stamp4EUFAM, so if i link to your above line 1year stamp4EUFAM .. you can't apply. again if you have stamp...

@richard12: don't mixed 2 things.. just for understanding let me share the process.. lets assume currently you are on Stamp4 EUFAM, and you guys are separated after 3.5 years.. from here first you need to retain your stamp4, for that you will need to fill the EU5 application form with all the requi...

Hi All, We have recently split up and going for divorce. Eufam valid for the next 14 months. I have recently spoken to a lawyer and they have told me to apply for retention of rights which is EU5. But the lawyer has also requested past 5 years documents like p60/bank statements/utility bills in my n...

Yes you need a person ID/application number
For that you must wait for an acknowledgement letter from INIS.

littlerr wrote: ↑

Wed Apr 24, 2019 12:55 am

No there is no such thing

Can you please elaborate ??

Guys just a quick question.

Is Carta d’identità (Italian permanent residence card) sufficient to secure employment in Ireland ?? given that the holder of such residence card is a Non-EU citizen.
Please provide references if applicable.
Thankyou

Jack

Their is a requirement of applicants bank statement but not sure why they have asked you for last 5 years day to day transactions. You should consult a lawyer and they should write a letter explaining that bank account does exist but not maintained in last 5 years. It doesn't look like that by not p...

People dont necessarily use their card on a day to day basis so daily transactions may not be obtained. If i were you i would just simply write them that your wife does have a bank account but she hasn't used it in last 5 years as she depends on you and you afford all the expenses. By the way if you...

They sent the letter only requesting the bank statements or something else too? Have they given you any other options by which i mean if the statememts are not available?

Since when the immigration started ringing the landlord? They usually ring the workplace to confirm the employment. Its very unusual. In my case the landlord was not willing to give his phone number but just the email so does that mean they will require his phone number?

Best option is the employment of the EU citizen. If not that the EU citizen must be self employed or studying in a college. But they myst be engaged in any one of the activity listed in the form EU1. If you cannot show any of these activity than your application for a residence card may be refused.