HarryJones wrote:You did not seem to directly answer the question.
I mean did HMRC give you a new SA302?

HMRC given updated SA302.

@ ash2017 were you given a new/correct SA302 reflecting the amendments? Last five year SA302's were submitted and only 1 year had an amendment (without amendment also we were qualifying. But once they did not included the dividends on the face value of refusal and 2ndly they have taken net dividend...

Obie wrote:Well i am really not sure if i have Veto power over your representatives.

The UKVI are legally bound to seek further evidence under the Evidence flexibility provision but they did not.

You can try their option, but i have little faith in it.

Wish you all the best.

Thanks Obie

Then a JR will be most appropriate, or he can never possibly succeed on the same evidence. You have no statutory right of appeal, so the Upper Tribunal will determine the facts. Thanks Obie. We have been given with the opinion that if we submit a fresh application then we can include: ct600 + accou...

Then a JR will be most appropriate, or he can never possibly succeed on the same evidence. You have no statutory right of appeal, so the Upper Tribunal will determine the facts. Thanks Obie. We have been given with the opinion that if we submit a fresh application then we can include: ct600 + accou...

Obie wrote:Thanks Casa. You have a great attention to details.

@ OP, if deception accept is removed, which operative of the refusal remains.

Under AR Refusal19 (I) (j), balance of probability that earnings are not genuine.
Under PAP refusal earnings claimed with HO and HMRC are inconsistent.

If he came in 2008, why is he applying 2016 for ILR, I though he would have qualified since 2012 or 2013 at the latest. Does he currently have leave to remain. I cant see much good coming out of a new application. Once they refuse under deception, subsequent application are refused on the basis of ...

Hi All, I need your help on our case, details are given below: My husband is on tier 1 general visa and I am dependent. He received 1st entry clearance in 2008 but we came to reside in 2011. He is taking salary + dividends from his company. We applied for ILR by PEO appointment. CW asked for a quest...