A quick one for everyone with deep knowledge of the EU Directive 2004/38/EC. 1. How do you define a non financially dependent family member in the EU directive? 2. Is a non financially dependent non EEA family member considered a "family member" for the purpose of visa applications under ...
Hi all, My American boyfriend and myself recently got engaged. We have been together almost 2 years.......I live in Ireland and he lives in New York and we have spent the last 2 years constantly going back and forth visiting each other. We have finally decided enough is enough! :-) Our plan is to m...
Walrus..... You said: What is your point? Irish law made in clear that there was no automatic right to stay in Ireland or come to Ireland just because a member of your family is Irish. That was made clear regarding spouses in the 1980's and parents of Irish Child in 2003. My point is that Ireland n...
Does anyone know if this case has been heard yet / if there was an outcome? Seems directly related to the OP's query. Leave was granted, but its only leave http://www.courts.ie/__80256F2B00356A6B.nsf/0/16A9C141A75B5853802578CB004E71A1?Open&Highlight=0,O'Leary,~language_en~ Still to be considered
there is no law in relation to residency in ireland for the parents of irish nationals. if they come on c visit visa, they must go back after 90 days. c visit visa cannot be extended. On the Contrary Lobe 2003 Supreme Court Dimbo 2008 Supreme Court And numerous High Court cases like Hassan 2010. Th...
Walrus... You said: To answer your question, the department would likely have refused the visas because the department knew that they would overstay and because there was no legal entitlement, under Irish law too family reunification. It is not a case of probability that the department refused visa...
It does not have to be over. Just nonsense from people like Morris has stopped. Any further discussion, including you, outside this case or any other similar case is not welcome. You can always just ignore it.
Thx iqu,walrusgumble, rlow68 and malaika i think i dont have to apply through naturalisation as my wife have been living here 3yrs right before my daughter born. My child should be an Irish citizen in terms of reckonable residence of one of the parent's. Now guys could you point out what sort of do...
I have a new born baby daughter in last week of October, 2011. My wife is an EU citizen and i am holding Eu Fam 4 issued currently. My wife's official residence as per revenue record here in Ireland since october 2009. She was a student learning english since September 2008-sept 2009 and she was no...
I have a new born baby daughter in last week of October, 2011. My wife is an EU citizen and i am holding Eu Fam 4 issued currently. My wife's official residence as per revenue record here in Ireland since october 2009. She was a student learning english since September 2008-sept 2009 and she was no...
Walrus, I would never advocate for any one to purposely break immigration laws, that is unacceptable, however I read some of the cases on the links you gave. The state's arguement was that while they acknowledge the right of the Irish child, more emphasis should be placed on common good, which is t...
Walrus, Your description of cronyism and nepotism is not restricted to Ireland, most countries have this problem as well but maybe perhaps it is more accentuated in Ireland because the country while been a small open economy still exhibits insular behavior. The case here is the systematic discrimin...
I observed two things about you. Anyone that does not support your view,you conclude he/she is not Irish and tend to know about their country of Origin,now am saying why dont you,Mr wals post your full names,D.O.B and location,I know you from Ireland but where?U like that ehh?Tho you mentioned the ...
lol you gonna look for where the Anti-immigrants criticized the British?Thought you knew him better,He edits most of his comment after seeing his error,so plz do not bother.I already knew his kind of person when Zambrano ruling came out.Lil kids can easily point out who Mr wals is,by reading his po...
Walrus, you would go to any length to support your discriminatory views towards immigrants. The summary of the research commissioned by the equality authority and carried out by ERSI is as follows: The study showed: Irish applicants were called to interview 78 times while minority candidates were i...
Walrus, are you incapable of reading and comprehending a simple article? I would provide it again- http://www.independent.ie/national-news/racism-rife-as-irish-twice-as-likely-to-be-given-job-1731224.html I said to you that this discriminatory attitude of the Irish towards immigrants could explain ...
I have warned you on several occassions walrusgumble that your lovely packed peverse ideologies on immigrant is not welcomed on this forum. You have started picking on specific ethnicity to fulfill your rabid fantacies and views and this will not be tolerated under any circumstance. You are seeking...
Walrusgumble, you are loosing the plot now aren't you? I did not go around other sites looking for you! I went to other sites to read on a particular case that I was interested in (the beloved of an elected Irish politician towards black Africans) and I noticed you were there pathetically justifyin...
if both the parties have same domicile belongs to same country pakistan. SO the pakistan divorce recognised under irish law? If you go back to foriegn decree act 1985 under irish law both party to such marraige/devorce must be domicile in the country where the divorce was obtained, one party domici...
Walrusgumble Great to see you took my advise and paragraphed your post- easier to read and follow your line of thought. However, it is still full of embellishments, inaccuracies and awash of definitive comments on issues you are not in a position to make. Firstly, you asked me to point out your inc...
if both the parties have same domicile belongs to same country pakistan. SO the pakistan divorce recognised under irish law? If you go back to foriegn decree act 1985 under irish law both party to such marraige/devorce must be domicile in the country where the divorce was obtained, one party domici...
@wals i said am done arguing with you,You can bang your head against Eu-law or wait to become minister of Justice,then you can include your desire into the Irish law, when Zambrano ruling came out,even tho it was both non eu parents,you werent happy,you had to compare the law romanians.You said why...
A. I would take a step back on the Article 40.1 argument. Though, for benefit of doubt , I should ask you to clarify. Article 40.1 is one of the most weakest Constitutional provisions in Irish Law. There is no such thing as Equality for all. You treat like for like , you don't threat unlike the sam...
Walrus, you do not need to reply to a single post with 4 different posts, you could have explicated yourself in the same post with four different paragraphs- you know what that is? As usual your posts are awash with inconsistencies and goes a long way in confirming people's suspicion about your mot...
