Fair enough. I did find the proof of dependency very difficult, as we weren't sending money to them before they came here. So really just had to scrape all the paperwork I had and send it off. Good luck to all.
DOJ asked the following: "Documentary evidence from the relevant authority in your country of origin (South Africa) or the contry from which you arrived in Ireland certifying that you are a dependent, or a member of the household of the EU Citizen, CMoses." See below copied from my letter ...
Received our letter of approval today for my in-laws under EU Treaty Rights. Timeline as follows: Application: 12/05/2009 Request more docs: 26/05/2009 Sent in docs: 28/05/2009 Refusal: 16/10/2009 Appeal: /10/2009 Request for evidence of dependency docs: 3/12/2009 Sent in letter pointing out descrep...
I received a letter back from DOJ referring to my letter saying that under the Directive and SI 656 their request is not applicable. They wrote within 2 days saying that the contents of my letter have been noted and that they will be in contact with me in due course regarding same. I suppose they ha...
No prob, send in P60s again if you have copies, just to be double sure. Do you know how to prove dependency and member of household? I am struggling with that. Am going to send in VHI that I paid for for my parents, and also car and insurance I bought for them. I cant think of anything else.
Hi there, I had this as well on my application. If you are not registered with Social as unemployed, do this and send them that letter, and also register with FAS and send them that confirmation. Also P60s for the last two years. They were happy with that when I sent it in.
Hi there, they have been living with us for 7 months and we have been feeding, clothing etc them. We didnt support them in South Africa, as they were working and just retired when they found out they wouldnt get a pension. They they came here to us. How can we prove dependency or that they are membe...
Thanks for that.. We have written to them explaining the situation and ages (sorry 66 and 72) that they are retired, had a small pension (€5,000) and therefore the South African Government would not give them a state pension. (We sent them a original of that letter). Only daughter in SA has a brai...
I trawled through both the SI 656 and Directive 2004/38 and couldnt find a reference to prove this in relation to "qualifying" family members. We had already provided to them letters froom the South African government denying them pensions and explained that they are too old to work there ...
Just got a refusal for my in-laws (South African) for a residence permit on the basis I did not prove sufficiently that they are dependent on us. I am Uk and husband naturalised Irish. I wrote them a letter back quoting Directive 2004/38 and SI 656 that I dont need to prove that, that they are direc...
