It was proper marriage, we were first living together 2 years in Ireland, then we got married and another 2 years living together. Then she left me but we still marriage. This will be the only one problem that we lived together only 2 years and she left me and i didnt inform immigration. But u know...
I know what you said, but you can't invoke a spirit into the Directive that was not clearly intended. Zambrano says nothing that assists the op in the question that still needs answering. Also, there are now question marks as to whether Zambrano applies in general or whether it applies to only wher...
You may be right, but you say the spirit of the Directive. You can't impose obligations of the Directive on a Member State, when its clear that the applicant does not comply with that Directive. I mention that its against the spirit of the Directive as Directive 2004/38 is commonly called the Citiz...
Hello everyone, I posted on here previously about been denied PR on the basis of marraige to a British citizen. I have decided to appeal this decision but to be on the safe side and mitigate my lack of immigration status in the state, I have been adviced by people to apply based on the Zambrano dec...
It took me roughly 6months, I married early 2009 and I applied for stamp 4 early 2010 and by the middle of 2010 I got my stamp 4. I have my stamp for a year and half now. But I was told one can apply once the couple have lived together counting from the day they got married. I read this and I got c...
I would like to seek the help of the good people on this forum. I arrived Ireland with my spouse who is British June 2006 and in August recieved a 5 year EU residence permit. I made an application for permanent residence in April of this year and I got a refusal letter this morning. My situation is...
Hello Forum, This website was recommended to me by a friend and I will like the opinion of members. I recently got a Stamp 4 as the parent of an Irish child based on the Zambrano law, I was under the impression that since this right was under the auspices of the EU, no fees would be attached. Howev...
Dear all, I have been living in Irelag nd since 2003. I came here aged 15 and on the basis of a joint parent visa. I was first given a GNIB card when I turned 16 and was given a stamp 2. I have since then graduated from college and finished my masters (all in Ireland). My father has a stamp 4 and h...
Thank you. This friend was Deported in 2005, he came back to the UK in 2006, now lives in Northern Ireland married to an Irish national with wife and Irish children, Because Northern Ireland is part of Island of Ireland He is entitled to apply for Irish citizenship based on his legal status in Nort...
Do you know how many Irish people on social welfare for the past few years who are not making any contribution and are not ready to get up and make any atall ? Irrelevant. I'm referring to you not contributing to this discussion. This website is created to help people understand their immigration r...
I know it will never make sense, that's a tactics from dearly beloved to blacks to substantiate their points in making them feel good or right for the wrong they did. If i can be convicted fro talking and let you people off without any penalty for insult, i don't waste my time in taken anything you...
about one month ago.I don't think it's a backlog in the usual sense, but rather a process of the 2 Depts coming to an agreement on the policy (and procedure) on these cases. Zambrano Denial I got my passport back today and the reasons for denial was 1. Authenticity of documents 2. Immigration histo...
Hello everyone ,I may need your advice on my situation. I am a non eu national got married with a eu national in March 2007, holding stamp4 eu fam card for 5 years which valid till May 2012. My wife and myself are going to get divirce in later this year as we have not been living together for 4 yea...
I believe that the Irish Legislation allows for visa free travel for holders of a residence card issued under Article 10 so that the wording of the card should not matter as there will inevitably be wording differences on the cards. As long as it is issued under Article 10 of the 2004/38 Directive....
I applied for my wifes naturalisation last week and got a standard letter with reference number saying application is in cronological order blah blah blah....few of my friends told me they send back application if its not proper. does that means they have counted the dates and pre checked all the d...
On other note, what stamp they will put in the passport? In theory they should not stamp your passport if you have a Residence Card. You should ask them not to stamp it, and refer to the SI which prohibits stamping passports when then holder has a Residence Card. But... The way that Ireland has all...
It's a long story, but it's about my Irish citizenship and I want a high court order, how do I go about doing it and how long does it take and do I have to pay a fee? Would really appreciate some help! Thank youuu! I'm presuming you're talking about taking judicial review proceedings due to a delay...
Tone of the posts on this forum is degenerating daily. It's also getting to be more and more of a pain in the a** to wade through the ENORMOUS posts which seem to be getting more and more nasty by the day. It would be great if posts could stick to the topics and if people who want to have legal disc...
The Zambrano case was an Article 234 reference so the relevant Court in Belgium obviously were of the opinion that the matter involved an issue of EU Law. Obviously the Court itself and I belive the Advocate General didn't have any issues with jurisdiction of the ECJ. Zambrano is a special case, as ...
Hi guys! Does it mean if I have bad character(road offence,drunken driving whitout insurance,finally-3years out of road and fine 200 euro) If I have the oportunity to be an irish citizen ? That's a quite serious offence. I would suggest that you apply for Citizenship 10 years after the conviction a...
Grrr..I dislike blind arguments,people should start seeing things around b4 posting,to make it simpler,Fatty i do agree with u,Muttnuts no disrespect,i think u r a solicitor in d ripping business. check out Conor Obriain solicitors having Michael Lynn as their junior counsel,also with Greg Oniel so...
€1,000 would POSSIBLY cover the cost of Junior Counsel drafting the required papers for an application for JR. This does not cover the cost of meeting with the clients, taking instructions, analysing the merits of the case, seeking the various documents etc, all the work required by the solicitor...
You went in length and breadth explaining where that 1,000 quids went, like you have some sort of a case to ans. I did not suggest Brophy are Sh*te they maybe great at what they do. But a proper immigration solicitor would work out looking at scenarios at his/her disposal in first consultation. Its...
You are sorted then, your son born in 2010 is Irish provided you show your Latvian wife living history, her exercising treaty rights (p60/p21/bills/statements etc) as per immigration lawyer suggestion. I am kind of amazed as to why Brophy did not cop on to that. I wonder why ... £$ . I'm amazed at...
