My name is Rydhwan and I exercised treaty rights in Dublin, Ireland for almost 2 years.
I went there in June 2014. I got my Mrs over there in Oct 2014 and she got her GNIB card in July 15. We also have a daughter born in Dublin in June 15.
We returned last year in April. I applied for her residence card application in November.
Now it's been refused and there are some interesting refusal points.
1) You have provided no/insufficient evidence of your integration in the Republic of Ireland.
2) It is suspected that your first lawful residence with your sponsor was in order to circumvent immigration law.
We have submitted everything, which includes tenancy agreement, bank statements, bills, PRTB, my wife hospital records, daughter's birth certificate, salary slip, tax certificate, Company documents when I went self employed. We had a baby in June so after that my Mrs was very busy until we return here, she was pregnant with 2nd child and our 2nd one was born last year in November
![Surprised :o](./images/smilies/icon_surprised.gif)
Anyway in the refusal they pointed out my statement regarding BBC article on treaty rights, they further pointed out a course in April 14 which I attended for 2 days regarding Static security and said that I could have performed a similar role here in UK.
Their 2nd refusal explanation was that I mention that we were struggling with finances at the end of our stay and did not have any proper work and I wanted to come back to UK because most of my family & friends are here, according to them this further raises the question as to why I would choose to leave UK to go to Ireland in the first instance.
Lastly they said that Mrs have been granted permission until 2020 and we have left Ireland within 9 months of getting the residence card, again according to them if we genuinely wanted to stay in Ireland, it would have expected of me to find more employment there, rather than returning to UK.
I am planning to appeal as they have not returned my wife's passport and suggesting that she can be deported. I wanted to argue over these points with reference to legislation.
Can someone direct me on some good points? I transferred my center of life to Ireland (I don't own a property or business in UK) hence my lengthy stay there so how come they do this to us especially with 2 infants, one is 2 years in June and the other is 9 months old.
Is there no justice?
Thank you