Hi Leiignacio28,
You are misunderstanding some important point..
You have to understand the difference between EEA PERMIT AND EEA FAMILY MEMBER RESIDENCE CARD..
EEA FAMILY PERMIT can only be applied from outside Uk and its just an entry Stamp to travel with your EU National Spouse. so if you are already in Uk, you don't need an entry Stamp to enter UK while you are already in UK.
While a EEA FAMILY MEMBER Residence Card is a 5years residence Card which is a prove of Residence in UK under your EU national Spouse.
Which means, if you are already in UK and want to continue to live in UK with your EU National Spouse, you shouldn't be talking about
EEA PERMIT RATHER YOU SHOULD BE TALKING ABOUT EEA FAMILY MEMBER RESIDENCE CARD
Summery! Someone who already has Uk visa of any type, even without a valid Visa but are in UK, shouldn't be talking about EEA FAMILY PERMIT, rather he or she should be talking about EEA FAMILY MEMBER RESIDENCE CARD..
Your main point should be RESIDENCE CARD APPLICATION UNDER YOUR EU NATION SPONSOR.
Here is the link/guidance
https://www.gov.uk/government/publicati ... orm-eea-fm
And again, if any of your friends application was rejected then its probably because the applicant doesn't meet the requirements, an error in application or missing documents.
It can never be because you are applying with a Tourist visa or because you are already an overstayer.
NEVER!
You dont necessarily need a lawyer to make this application, just make sure you meet all the requirements for a EEA FAMILY MEMBER RESIDENCE CARD
I had this same issue and i'm giving you a correct information from a first hand information from UK IMMIGRATION.