- FAQ
- Login
- Register
- Call Workpermit.com for a paid service +44 (0)344-991-9222
Immigration, work visa and work permit discussion board
ESC
Welcome to immigrationboards.com!
Moderators: Casa, Amber, archigabe, batleykhan, ca.funke, ChetanOjha, EUsmileWEallsmile, JAJ, John, Obie, push, geriatrix, vinny, CR001, zimba, meself2, Administrator
headley wrote:
Here are my updated details. BTW Big thank you to everyone in the forum.
headley WP to Tier 1 with HSMP Letter
SENT APPLICATION: April 29
HO RECEIVED APPLI: April 30
REFERENCE LETTER RECEIVED: May 6
Called HO: May 28 told not assigned to case worker yet.
APPROVAL: Letter dated May 30 valid for 3yrs till 2011.
DOCS RECEIVED: June 12
To everyone still waiting. I wish you all the very best of luck.
Remember, keep hope alive everyone. Your time will come soon even when times may look sad. I have been hoping and hoping everyday and finally my time has come so too will yours.
Stay positive everyone.
Big thank you again to everyone in forum.
headley
aamirmalik wrote:well kmore i believe you people are right. my case might be refused. your point is valid in this case. the tax return from july03 to june 04 gives total money earned during last 7 months but then i have given full detail in excel sheet
like gross salary in tax return july03 to june04 was Rs 702,000
in excel i have given all detail
year gross income tax deducted
july 03 RS 55,000 tax fig here#
aug 03 RS 55,000 #
sept03 RS 55,000 #
oct 03 RS 55,000 #
nov 03 RS 55,000 #
dec 03 RS 55,000 #
payrise
jan 04 RS 62,000 #
feb 04 RS 62,000 #
mar04 RS 62,000 #
apr 04 RS 62,000 #
may04 RS 62,000 #
jun 04 RS 62,000
total Rs 702,000
and explaination for rest of the 6 months exactly like this has been submitted along with documents.
Kmore and sushdmehta thank you realy for your replies....great help
im worried...if i get refused then ill arrange bank statments...but for now i will wait lets see. may be i get approval...but i believe chances r less as susdmehta assessment seems to be right
thanks u
kmore97 wrote:Aamir,
As I explained in my previous post, if CW is able to derive ur jan04-Dec04 figures from ur tax documents - u r safe.
I understand ur tax challan point. CW will be able to derive ur earning for jul04 to dec04. What about Jul03 - Jun04 tax return document? Is it extensive enuf for caseworker to find out ur earning from jan04 to jun04?
aamirmalik wrote:can anybody comment plz
leme explain wat i submited again...
i came here in january 2005 as a student and was working in pakistan before that. I submitted 12 moth salary slips from january04 to december 04. tax year in pakistan is june to july therefore submitted tax return from july03 to june04. it is covering only 6months jan04 to june04. for the rest of the months i have submitted tax challans for each months with official tax stamp from authority. these challans for each month shows the total gross salary and total tax deducted for each month.
kmore i can try to arrange a bank statment but it will take some time. my case might be allocated in one week time.
i have submitted explaination about the tax and salary for 12 months in excel sheet for caseworker's understanding. i understand it is a bit complexed but not very difficult for him to understand if he check it carefully and read my explaination in excel prinout...wat do u suggest kmore??? please comment
!!! I bet you would be engrossed now checking your documents again and again headley wrote:Thanks Vipul and chakde23.
Passport stamp says valid June 11 until 30th May.
If it was stamped June 11 that would mean I got it next day. Hm.......
They sent a another letter verifying my points but that one is dated May 30th.
headley
notty wrote:I have just read all the comments on ur case.
Lokesh said that u can not submit payslips and tax returns as both consider from the same source but how come these r from same source, payslips are from employer and tax returns stamped by the tax authorities with covering letter from tax authorities that applicant has paid that much tax in this year on the IT headed paper.
Yes employer submits the tax returns but to tax authorities and tax authorities confirms it by stamping and letter. and in Pakistan most of the times employee takes salary cash in hand and at the end of the tax year he submits his tax returns on his own by self assessment criteria. in any case tax returns are consider from tax authorities not from employer, coz u r paying tax to IT office not to employer.
so payslips and tax returns fulfill the evidence requirement.
and u can submit payslips along with tax returns if it corroborate the exact period u r claiming.
in ur case i think (my opinion) CW shud giv u points for 6 months from Jan04 to June04 because tax returns corroborate that period with payslips i dnt know about tax challans CW would consider it or not?if CW accepts challan as an evidence then well n gud but if GOD forbid CW doesnt accept that then
HO will consider 15 months period before u become full time student and they take any 12 consecutive months from these 15 months and earnings assessed on how much u earn in ur whole working period not per month and doesn't matter u earned in 12 months or in 6 months, if ur total earnings in six months are enough to get required points then it shud work, so u can show ur earnings from oct03, so if u call HO and discuss this with dem and send dem more three payslips for 0ct03, nov03 and dec03, and they already got ur tax returns for that period.
according to ur salary 55000/month
in 6 months = 330000 = GBP2870 (if in 2004 GBP1=Rs115) = which is equivalent to 15209GBP
so according to 6 months situation u cant get any point for previous earnings but
in 9 months = 495000 = GBP4304 (if in 2004 GBP1=Rs115) = which is equivalent to 22813GBP
according to 9 months earnings u can get 15 points.
so if these 15 points can take u to the total of 75 then dont waist a minute and fone HO and discuss this and send them three payslips with covering letter ASAP.
if these 15 points are not enough then leave all the things on ur luck and pray for the best.
aamirmalik wrote:well kmore i believe you people are right. my case might be refused. your point is valid in this case. the tax return from july03 to june 04 gives total money earned during last 7 months but then i have given full detail in excel sheet
like gross salary in tax return july03 to june04 was Rs 702,000
in excel i have given all detail
year gross income tax deducted
july 03 RS 55,000 tax fig here#
aug 03 RS 55,000 #
sept03 RS 55,000 #
oct 03 RS 55,000 #
nov 03 RS 55,000 #
dec 03 RS 55,000 #
payrise
jan 04 RS 62,000 #
feb 04 RS 62,000 #
mar04 RS 62,000 #
apr 04 RS 62,000 #
may04 RS 62,000 #
jun 04 RS 62,000
total Rs 702,000
and explaination for rest of the 6 months exactly like this has been submitted along with documents.
Kmore and sushdmehta thank you realy for your replies....great help
im worried...if i get refused then ill arrange bank statments...but for now i will wait lets see. may be i get approval...but i believe chances r less as susdmehta assessment seems to be right
thanks u
kmore97 wrote:Aamir,
As I explained in my previous post, if CW is able to derive ur jan04-Dec04 figures from ur tax documents - u r safe.
I understand ur tax challan point. CW will be able to derive ur earning for jul04 to dec04. What about Jul03 - Jun04 tax return document? Is it extensive enuf for caseworker to find out ur earning from jan04 to jun04?
aamirmalik wrote:can anybody comment plz
leme explain wat i submited again...
i came here in january 2005 as a student and was working in pakistan before that. I submitted 12 moth salary slips from january04 to december 04. tax year in pakistan is june to july therefore submitted tax return from july03 to june04. it is covering only 6months jan04 to june04. for the rest of the months i have submitted tax challans for each months with official tax stamp from authority. these challans for each month shows the total gross salary and total tax deducted for each month.
kmore i can try to arrange a bank statment but it will take some time. my case might be allocated in one week time.
i have submitted explaination about the tax and salary for 12 months in excel sheet for caseworker's understanding. i understand it is a bit complexed but not very difficult for him to understand if he check it carefully and read my explaination in excel prinout...wat do u suggest kmore??? please comment
kmore97 wrote:So the monthwise, break-up is totally ur declaration. Ur tax document doesn't indicate that. So as sushdmehta indicated, u'll consider urself lucky if approval comes.
As it's already too late to arrange bank statements - then probably you have no option but rely on ur luck and wait.
Please keep posted after u hear something from HO. Best of luck, meanwhile!
aamirmalik wrote:well kmore i believe you people are right. my case might be refused. your point is valid in this case. the tax return from july03 to june 04 gives total money earned during last 7 months but then i have given full detail in excel sheet
like gross salary in tax return july03 to june04 was Rs 702,000
in excel i have given all detail
year gross income tax deducted
july 03 RS 55,000 tax fig here#
aug 03 RS 55,000 #
sept03 RS 55,000 #
oct 03 RS 55,000 #
nov 03 RS 55,000 #
dec 03 RS 55,000 #
payrise
jan 04 RS 62,000 #
feb 04 RS 62,000 #
mar04 RS 62,000 #
apr 04 RS 62,000 #
may04 RS 62,000 #
jun 04 RS 62,000
total Rs 702,000
and explaination for rest of the 6 months exactly like this has been submitted along with documents.
Kmore and sushdmehta thank you realy for your replies....great help
im worried...if i get refused then ill arrange bank statments...but for now i will wait lets see. may be i get approval...but i believe chances r less as susdmehta assessment seems to be right
thanks u
kmore97 wrote:Aamir,
As I explained in my previous post, if CW is able to derive ur jan04-Dec04 figures from ur tax documents - u r safe.
I understand ur tax challan point. CW will be able to derive ur earning for jul04 to dec04. What about Jul03 - Jun04 tax return document? Is it extensive enuf for caseworker to find out ur earning from jan04 to jun04?
aamirmalik wrote:can anybody comment plz
leme explain wat i submited again...
i came here in january 2005 as a student and was working in pakistan before that. I submitted 12 moth salary slips from january04 to december 04. tax year in pakistan is june to july therefore submitted tax return from july03 to june04. it is covering only 6months jan04 to june04. for the rest of the months i have submitted tax challans for each months with official tax stamp from authority. these challans for each month shows the total gross salary and total tax deducted for each month.
kmore i can try to arrange a bank statment but it will take some time. my case might be allocated in one week time.
i have submitted explaination about the tax and salary for 12 months in excel sheet for caseworker's understanding. i understand it is a bit complexed but not very difficult for him to understand if he check it carefully and read my explaination in excel prinout...wat do u suggest kmore??? please comment
aamirmalik wrote:sushdmehta plz comment. im trying to get my bank statment from pakistan. Should i ask them to send monthly bank statement or it can be a a continous 1 bankstatment giving all the trascation from jan to dec????
vipul1981 wrote:notty dont say with so much confidence that tax returns and payslips are not from same source.
They very well can be from same source. for instance in UK, tax return form P6o is considered as same source as pay slips. Although tax is pais to tax office.
2ndly in Amirs case, his application does look quite vague.
My advice to him is to keep the bank statements ready, just incase he needs it.
Its not about right or wrong , point here is to convince the CW. It has been seen in recent past that many applicants have been declined because of this.
laskk wrote:Notty:-
Yes , you arte right.
Pay slips are from the employer n IT from Tax authority. So defently they are from different sources.
As far as Ammirmalik case is concern if he can manage his Bank statement, i think its Good 4 him ( in case CW contact him for supp. document).
Im not sure whether he can send now additional supporting document to BIA. If he can, so he have to make it( to avoid the risk). As we has seen the cases in april this Year,applicant got rejection on Tax document. so thats shows us BIA CW's need clear document.
Kind Regards,
Laskk
notty wrote:I have just read all the comments on ur case.
Lokesh said that u can not submit payslips and tax returns as both consider from the same source but how come these r from same source, payslips are from employer and tax returns stamped by the tax authorities with covering letter from tax authorities that applicant has paid that much tax in this year on the IT headed paper.
Yes employer submits the tax returns but to tax authorities and tax authorities confirms it by stamping and letter. and in Pakistan most of the times employee takes salary cash in hand and at the end of the tax year he submits his tax returns on his own by self assessment criteria. in any case tax returns are consider from tax authorities not from employer, coz u r paying tax to IT office not to employer.
so payslips and tax returns fulfill the evidence requirement.
and u can submit payslips along with tax returns if it corroborate the exact period u r claiming.
in ur case i think (my opinion) CW shud giv u points for 6 months from Jan04 to June04 because tax returns corroborate that period with payslips i dnt know about tax challans CW would consider it or not?if CW accepts challan as an evidence then well n gud but if GOD forbid CW doesnt accept that then
HO will consider 15 months period before u become full time student and they take any 12 consecutive months from these 15 months and earnings assessed on how much u earn in ur whole working period not per month and doesn't matter u earned in 12 months or in 6 months, if ur total earnings in six months are enough to get required points then it shud work, so u can show ur earnings from oct03, so if u call HO and discuss this with dem and send dem more three payslips for 0ct03, nov03 and dec03, and they already got ur tax returns for that period.
according to ur salary 55000/month
in 6 months = 330000 = GBP2870 (if in 2004 GBP1=Rs115) = which is equivalent to 15209GBP
so according to 6 months situation u cant get any point for previous earnings but
in 9 months = 495000 = GBP4304 (if in 2004 GBP1=Rs115) = which is equivalent to 22813GBP
according to 9 months earnings u can get 15 points.
so if these 15 points can take u to the total of 75 then dont waist a minute and fone HO and discuss this and send them three payslips with covering letter ASAP.
if these 15 points are not enough then leave all the things on ur luck and pray for the best.
aamirmalik wrote:well kmore i believe you people are right. my case might be refused. your point is valid in this case. the tax return from july03 to june 04 gives total money earned during last 7 months but then i have given full detail in excel sheet
like gross salary in tax return july03 to june04 was Rs 702,000
in excel i have given all detail
year gross income tax deducted
july 03 RS 55,000 tax fig here#
aug 03 RS 55,000 #
sept03 RS 55,000 #
oct 03 RS 55,000 #
nov 03 RS 55,000 #
dec 03 RS 55,000 #
payrise
jan 04 RS 62,000 #
feb 04 RS 62,000 #
mar04 RS 62,000 #
apr 04 RS 62,000 #
may04 RS 62,000 #
jun 04 RS 62,000
total Rs 702,000
and explaination for rest of the 6 months exactly like this has been submitted along with documents.
Kmore and sushdmehta thank you realy for your replies....great help
im worried...if i get refused then ill arrange bank statments...but for now i will wait lets see. may be i get approval...but i believe chances r less as susdmehta assessment seems to be right
thanks u
kmore97 wrote:Aamir,
As I explained in my previous post, if CW is able to derive ur jan04-Dec04 figures from ur tax documents - u r safe.
I understand ur tax challan point. CW will be able to derive ur earning for jul04 to dec04. What about Jul03 - Jun04 tax return document? Is it extensive enuf for caseworker to find out ur earning from jan04 to jun04?
notty wrote:hi
could u plz tell me about those cases which r refused becoz of tax documents, did CW mention that u haven't provided two evidences from separate source.
may b in those cases tax returns didnt reflect the exact period which they r claiming for. just like amirs case his tax returns is not reflecting the exact period.
i foned HO and asked that u r considering payslips and tax documents r from same source or it fulfills the requirement then they said yes it fulfills the requirement if it corroborate exact period and it is mention in policy guidance as well.
tell me about those cases what r the reasons of refusal.it may increase my knowledge. coz sometimes HO said something else n facts r something else. i experienced that by foning HO, two three times i foned n asked that for self employed person within company structure u consider gross income or net profit then they said gross income, gross income, gross income but in guidance policy it is clearly mention that points should b given on net profit then i called again n asked again he said again that on gross income then i said plz open the policy then after reading policy he was saying yes its not on gross income its on net profit.
so plz tell me about those cases which r refused on tax documents, what r the reasons of rejection mention there.
laskk wrote:Notty:-
Yes , you arte right.
Pay slips are from the employer n IT from Tax authority. So defently they are from different sources.
As far as Ammirmalik case is concern if he can manage his Bank statement, i think its Good 4 him ( in case CW contact him for supp. document).
Im not sure whether he can send now additional supporting document to BIA. If he can, so he have to make it( to avoid the risk). As we has seen the cases in april this Year,applicant got rejection on Tax document. so thats shows us BIA CW's need clear document.
Kind Regards,
Laskk
notty wrote:I have just read all the comments on ur case.
Lokesh said that u can not submit payslips and tax returns as both consider from the same source but how come these r from same source, payslips are from employer and tax returns stamped by the tax authorities with covering letter from tax authorities that applicant has paid that much tax in this year on the IT headed paper.
Yes employer submits the tax returns but to tax authorities and tax authorities confirms it by stamping and letter. and in Pakistan most of the times employee takes salary cash in hand and at the end of the tax year he submits his tax returns on his own by self assessment criteria. in any case tax returns are consider from tax authorities not from employer, coz u r paying tax to IT office not to employer.
so payslips and tax returns fulfill the evidence requirement.
and u can submit payslips along with tax returns if it corroborate the exact period u r claiming.
in ur case i think (my opinion) CW shud giv u points for 6 months from Jan04 to June04 because tax returns corroborate that period with payslips i dnt know about tax challans CW would consider it or not?if CW accepts challan as an evidence then well n gud but if GOD forbid CW doesnt accept that then
HO will consider 15 months period before u become full time student and they take any 12 consecutive months from these 15 months and earnings assessed on how much u earn in ur whole working period not per month and doesn't matter u earned in 12 months or in 6 months, if ur total earnings in six months are enough to get required points then it shud work, so u can show ur earnings from oct03, so if u call HO and discuss this with dem and send dem more three payslips for 0ct03, nov03 and dec03, and they already got ur tax returns for that period.
according to ur salary 55000/month
in 6 months = 330000 = GBP2870 (if in 2004 GBP1=Rs115) = which is equivalent to 15209GBP
so according to 6 months situation u cant get any point for previous earnings but
in 9 months = 495000 = GBP4304 (if in 2004 GBP1=Rs115) = which is equivalent to 22813GBP
according to 9 months earnings u can get 15 points.
so if these 15 points can take u to the total of 75 then dont waist a minute and fone HO and discuss this and send them three payslips with covering letter ASAP.
if these 15 points are not enough then leave all the things on ur luck and pray for the best.
aamirmalik wrote:well kmore i believe you people are right. my case might be refused. your point is valid in this case. the tax return from july03 to june 04 gives total money earned during last 7 months but then i have given full detail in excel sheet
like gross salary in tax return july03 to june04 was Rs 702,000
in excel i have given all detail
year gross income tax deducted
july 03 RS 55,000 tax fig here#
aug 03 RS 55,000 #
sept03 RS 55,000 #
oct 03 RS 55,000 #
nov 03 RS 55,000 #
dec 03 RS 55,000 #
payrise
jan 04 RS 62,000 #
feb 04 RS 62,000 #
mar04 RS 62,000 #
apr 04 RS 62,000 #
may04 RS 62,000 #
jun 04 RS 62,000
total Rs 702,000
and explaination for rest of the 6 months exactly like this has been submitted along with documents.
Kmore and sushdmehta thank you realy for your replies....great help
im worried...if i get refused then ill arrange bank statments...but for now i will wait lets see. may be i get approval...but i believe chances r less as susdmehta assessment seems to be right
thanks u
notty wrote:hi
could u plz tell me about those cases which r refused becoz of tax documents, did CW mention that u haven't provided two evidences from separate source.
may b in those cases tax returns didnt reflect the exact period which they r claiming for. just like amirs case his tax returns is not reflecting the exact period.
i foned HO and asked that u r considering payslips and tax documents r from same source or it fulfills the requirement then they said yes it fulfills the requirement if it corroborate exact period and it is mention in policy guidance as well.
tell me about those cases what r the reasons of refusal.it may increase my knowledge. coz sometimes HO said something else n facts r something else. i experienced that by foning HO, two three times i foned n asked that for self employed person within company structure u consider gross income or net profit then they said gross income, gross income, gross income but in guidance policy it is clearly mention that points should b given on net profit then i called again n asked again he said again that on gross income then i said plz open the policy then after reading policy he was saying yes its not on gross income its on net profit.
so plz tell me about those cases which r refused on tax documents, what r the reasons of rejection mention there.
laskk wrote:Notty:-
Yes , you arte right.
Pay slips are from the employer n IT from Tax authority. So defently they are from different sources.
As far as Ammirmalik case is concern if he can manage his Bank statement, i think its Good 4 him ( in case CW contact him for supp. document).
Im not sure whether he can send now additional supporting document to BIA. If he can, so he have to make it( to avoid the risk). As we has seen the cases in april this Year,applicant got rejection on Tax document. so thats shows us BIA CW's need clear document.
Kind Regards,
Laskk
notty wrote:I have just read all the comments on ur case.
Lokesh said that u can not submit payslips and tax returns as both consider from the same source but how come these r from same source, payslips are from employer and tax returns stamped by the tax authorities with covering letter from tax authorities that applicant has paid that much tax in this year on the IT headed paper.
Yes employer submits the tax returns but to tax authorities and tax authorities confirms it by stamping and letter. and in Pakistan most of the times employee takes salary cash in hand and at the end of the tax year he submits his tax returns on his own by self assessment criteria. in any case tax returns are consider from tax authorities not from employer, coz u r paying tax to IT office not to employer.
so payslips and tax returns fulfill the evidence requirement.
and u can submit payslips along with tax returns if it corroborate the exact period u r claiming.
in ur case i think (my opinion) CW shud giv u points for 6 months from Jan04 to June04 because tax returns corroborate that period with payslips i dnt know about tax challans CW would consider it or not?if CW accepts challan as an evidence then well n gud but if GOD forbid CW doesnt accept that then
HO will consider 15 months period before u become full time student and they take any 12 consecutive months from these 15 months and earnings assessed on how much u earn in ur whole working period not per month and doesn't matter u earned in 12 months or in 6 months, if ur total earnings in six months are enough to get required points then it shud work, so u can show ur earnings from oct03, so if u call HO and discuss this with dem and send dem more three payslips for 0ct03, nov03 and dec03, and they already got ur tax returns for that period.
according to ur salary 55000/month
in 6 months = 330000 = GBP2870 (if in 2004 GBP1=Rs115) = which is equivalent to 15209GBP
so according to 6 months situation u cant get any point for previous earnings but
in 9 months = 495000 = GBP4304 (if in 2004 GBP1=Rs115) = which is equivalent to 22813GBP
according to 9 months earnings u can get 15 points.
so if these 15 points can take u to the total of 75 then dont waist a minute and fone HO and discuss this and send them three payslips with covering letter ASAP.
if these 15 points are not enough then leave all the things on ur luck and pray for the best.
aamirmalik wrote:well kmore i believe you people are right. my case might be refused. your point is valid in this case. the tax return from july03 to june 04 gives total money earned during last 7 months but then i have given full detail in excel sheet
like gross salary in tax return july03 to june04 was Rs 702,000
in excel i have given all detail
year gross income tax deducted
july 03 RS 55,000 tax fig here#
aug 03 RS 55,000 #
sept03 RS 55,000 #
oct 03 RS 55,000 #
nov 03 RS 55,000 #
dec 03 RS 55,000 #
payrise
jan 04 RS 62,000 #
feb 04 RS 62,000 #
mar04 RS 62,000 #
apr 04 RS 62,000 #
may04 RS 62,000 #
jun 04 RS 62,000
total Rs 702,000
and explaination for rest of the 6 months exactly like this has been submitted along with documents.
Kmore and sushdmehta thank you realy for your replies....great help
im worried...if i get refused then ill arrange bank statments...but for now i will wait lets see. may be i get approval...but i believe chances r less as susdmehta assessment seems to be right
thanks u
aamirmalik wrote:notty, kmore, vippul, sushdmehta pleaseeeeeeeeeeee comment im giving you full detail...please read carefuly
documents i have submitted
1. Masters degree equalent to Uk Batchlers with Naric cert (30 points)
2. IELTS band 7(10)
3. 12 Payslips jan04 to dec04(35)
4. TAX RETURN with tax authorities stamp covering July03 to June04 Covering 6 months of Jan04 to Jun04 only.
5. 6 Tax challans covering july04 to Dec04 giving all details of gross income and tax deducted with tax authorities STAMP
6. Bank statment with 800 pounds.(10)
7. College Letters covering my 3.5 years study period in UK
8. Tax document explanation in EXCEL for CW's understanding
points claim 75
Additional documents
a letter from TAX commisioner confirming my tax from july03 to june04
letter include my gross income for the year 03/04 which was Rs.702000
and total annual tax deducted
leme explain to you guys
RS 55000*6+Rs62000=Rs702000
JAN04 to Dec04 my salary was Rs62000 which makes 62000*12=Rs744000 thats wat i have claimed....
out of 702000 salary for jan04 to jun04 was = RS 372,000
and from july04 to dec04 was again the same=RS 372000
which makes it RS 744,000 this is the amount i am claming
aamirmalik wrote:well im in trouble now. I spoke to the HO and they said my tax document might not be accepted. though i explained every thing. I dono what to do. My student visa is going to expire in july as well. Im in deep trouble. Some ppl say i should make a fake bank document. which i dont wana do...im too afraid to do that. its not easy to get a 3.5 year old bank statments. i have spoken to my relatives there but first of all bank will not entertain anybody else....secondly the statement will be more then 3 year old.....i dono wat to do and according to the time lines my case will be decided in 2 weeks times.....
notty wrote:hi
could u plz tell me about those cases which r refused becoz of tax documents, did CW mention that u haven't provided two evidences from separate source.
may b in those cases tax returns didnt reflect the exact period which they r claiming for. just like amirs case his tax returns is not reflecting the exact period.
i foned HO and asked that u r considering payslips and tax documents r from same source or it fulfills the requirement then they said yes it fulfills the requirement if it corroborate exact period and it is mention in policy guidance as well.
tell me about those cases what r the reasons of refusal.it may increase my knowledge. coz sometimes HO said something else n facts r something else. i experienced that by foning HO, two three times i foned n asked that for self employed person within company structure u consider gross income or net profit then they said gross income, gross income, gross income but in guidance policy it is clearly mention that points should b given on net profit then i called again n asked again he said again that on gross income then i said plz open the policy then after reading policy he was saying yes its not on gross income its on net profit.
so plz tell me about those cases which r refused on tax documents, what r the reasons of rejection mention there.
laskk wrote:Notty:-
Yes , you arte right.
Pay slips are from the employer n IT from Tax authority. So defently they are from different sources.
As far as Ammirmalik case is concern if he can manage his Bank statement, i think its Good 4 him ( in case CW contact him for supp. document).
Im not sure whether he can send now additional supporting document to BIA. If he can, so he have to make it( to avoid the risk). As we has seen the cases in april this Year,applicant got rejection on Tax document. so thats shows us BIA CW's need clear document.
Kind Regards,
Laskk
notty wrote:I have just read all the comments on ur case.
Lokesh said that u can not submit payslips and tax returns as both consider from the same source but how come these r from same source, payslips are from employer and tax returns stamped by the tax authorities with covering letter from tax authorities that applicant has paid that much tax in this year on the IT headed paper.
Yes employer submits the tax returns but to tax authorities and tax authorities confirms it by stamping and letter. and in Pakistan most of the times employee takes salary cash in hand and at the end of the tax year he submits his tax returns on his own by self assessment criteria. in any case tax returns are consider from tax authorities not from employer, coz u r paying tax to IT office not to employer.
so payslips and tax returns fulfill the evidence requirement.
and u can submit payslips along with tax returns if it corroborate the exact period u r claiming.
in ur case i think (my opinion) CW shud giv u points for 6 months from Jan04 to June04 because tax returns corroborate that period with payslips i dnt know about tax challans CW would consider it or not?if CW accepts challan as an evidence then well n gud but if GOD forbid CW doesnt accept that then
HO will consider 15 months period before u become full time student and they take any 12 consecutive months from these 15 months and earnings assessed on how much u earn in ur whole working period not per month and doesn't matter u earned in 12 months or in 6 months, if ur total earnings in six months are enough to get required points then it shud work, so u can show ur earnings from oct03, so if u call HO and discuss this with dem and send dem more three payslips for 0ct03, nov03 and dec03, and they already got ur tax returns for that period.
according to ur salary 55000/month
in 6 months = 330000 = GBP2870 (if in 2004 GBP1=Rs115) = which is equivalent to 15209GBP
so according to 6 months situation u cant get any point for previous earnings but
in 9 months = 495000 = GBP4304 (if in 2004 GBP1=Rs115) = which is equivalent to 22813GBP
according to 9 months earnings u can get 15 points.
so if these 15 points can take u to the total of 75 then dont waist a minute and fone HO and discuss this and send them three payslips with covering letter ASAP.
if these 15 points are not enough then leave all the things on ur luck and pray for the best.
aamirmalik wrote:well im in trouble now. I spoke to the HO and they said my tax document might not be accepted. though i explained every thing. I dono what to do. My student visa is going to expire in july as well. Im in deep trouble. Some ppl say i should make a fake bank document. which i dont wana do...im too afraid to do that. its not easy to get a 3.5 year old bank statments. i have spoken to my relatives there but first of all bank will not entertain anybody else....secondly the statement will be more then 3 year old.....i dono wat to do and according to the time lines my case will be decided in 2 weeks times.....
notty wrote:hi
could u plz tell me about those cases which r refused becoz of tax documents, did CW mention that u haven't provided two evidences from separate source.
may b in those cases tax returns didnt reflect the exact period which they r claiming for. just like amirs case his tax returns is not reflecting the exact period.
i foned HO and asked that u r considering payslips and tax documents r from same source or it fulfills the requirement then they said yes it fulfills the requirement if it corroborate exact period and it is mention in policy guidance as well.
tell me about those cases what r the reasons of refusal.it may increase my knowledge. coz sometimes HO said something else n facts r something else. i experienced that by foning HO, two three times i foned n asked that for self employed person within company structure u consider gross income or net profit then they said gross income, gross income, gross income but in guidance policy it is clearly mention that points should b given on net profit then i called again n asked again he said again that on gross income then i said plz open the policy then after reading policy he was saying yes its not on gross income its on net profit.
so plz tell me about those cases which r refused on tax documents, what r the reasons of rejection mention there.
laskk wrote:Notty:-
Yes , you arte right.
Pay slips are from the employer n IT from Tax authority. So defently they are from different sources.
As far as Ammirmalik case is concern if he can manage his Bank statement, i think its Good 4 him ( in case CW contact him for supp. document).
Im not sure whether he can send now additional supporting document to BIA. If he can, so he have to make it( to avoid the risk). As we has seen the cases in april this Year,applicant got rejection on Tax document. so thats shows us BIA CW's need clear document.
Kind Regards,
Laskk
notty wrote:I have just read all the comments on ur case.
Lokesh said that u can not submit payslips and tax returns as both consider from the same source but how come these r from same source, payslips are from employer and tax returns stamped by the tax authorities with covering letter from tax authorities that applicant has paid that much tax in this year on the IT headed paper.
Yes employer submits the tax returns but to tax authorities and tax authorities confirms it by stamping and letter. and in Pakistan most of the times employee takes salary cash in hand and at the end of the tax year he submits his tax returns on his own by self assessment criteria. in any case tax returns are consider from tax authorities not from employer, coz u r paying tax to IT office not to employer.
so payslips and tax returns fulfill the evidence requirement.
and u can submit payslips along with tax returns if it corroborate the exact period u r claiming.
in ur case i think (my opinion) CW shud giv u points for 6 months from Jan04 to June04 because tax returns corroborate that period with payslips i dnt know about tax challans CW would consider it or not?if CW accepts challan as an evidence then well n gud but if GOD forbid CW doesnt accept that then
HO will consider 15 months period before u become full time student and they take any 12 consecutive months from these 15 months and earnings assessed on how much u earn in ur whole working period not per month and doesn't matter u earned in 12 months or in 6 months, if ur total earnings in six months are enough to get required points then it shud work, so u can show ur earnings from oct03, so if u call HO and discuss this with dem and send dem more three payslips for 0ct03, nov03 and dec03, and they already got ur tax returns for that period.
according to ur salary 55000/month
in 6 months = 330000 = GBP2870 (if in 2004 GBP1=Rs115) = which is equivalent to 15209GBP
so according to 6 months situation u cant get any point for previous earnings but
in 9 months = 495000 = GBP4304 (if in 2004 GBP1=Rs115) = which is equivalent to 22813GBP
according to 9 months earnings u can get 15 points.
so if these 15 points can take u to the total of 75 then dont waist a minute and fone HO and discuss this and send them three payslips with covering letter ASAP.
if these 15 points are not enough then leave all the things on ur luck and pray for the best.
!!