- FAQ
- Login
- Register
- Call Workpermit.com for a paid service +44 (0)344-991-9222
ESC
Welcome to immigrationboards.com!
Moderators: Casa, Amber, archigabe, batleykhan, ca.funke, ChetanOjha, EUsmileWEallsmile, JAJ, John, Obie, push, geriatrix, vinny, CR001, zimba, meself2, Administrator
I think it is outrageous, why should it be their concern if other member states chooses to implement the directive correctly.uptimist wrote:I am Eu citizen residing with my family(non Eu with Stamp4 eu fam card).We both travelled to Germany.We got a good reception at Bremen because the IO seems to know she does not require a visa as long as we travel together.The funny thing is on our arrieval at ireland,the IO seems not to know his job he insisted that my wife should have got a visa for germany before leaving ireland.After a lot of talk,he said we were allowed in,with a warning from these almighty officer that he will note this on their system
On entry into Ireland my wife's passport (4EUFam-holder) was stamped roughly 50/50...Directive/2004/38/EC wrote:Did they stamp your or your wife's passport on entering Ireland?
Directive/2004/38/EC wrote:It makes you wonder about the Irish immigration Gardia! Wow!
My personal interpretation goes along these lines: They are not well-trained and do not know the regulations under which they work. Let alone the intention of the laws, which in turn would make the laws much more comprehensible.Obie wrote:...How could they stamp your wife's passport, when it is clearly stated in their regulation that it is forbidden. Worst of it asking your wife what she is coming to do here...
Colin Zwirko, 21, Gavin Sides, 19, and Ben Whitehurst, 21, said they were told when they landed in Dublin on Friday that they couldn’t enter the country because they didn’t have an address where they planned to stay and bank statements to prove they could afford to travel.
Wondering why they don't let the spouses of Irish citizens take the EU line as well? Although even if they did, there no doubt would be endless hassle.acme4242 wrote:I wonder did he even know his own job,
Under Irish law, SI 656 of 2006, He should not Stamp your wife's passport, Did he ?
and you are entitled to take the Irish/EU line with your wife (as she does not need a stamp)
I would not be happy with his threat, or what he might write.
Hmmm Well.... What happens if you are Irish and coming from working in another EU country with your spouse.... Then European law applies (Singh case). So those spouses of Irish people should be able to use the EU line. ....esharknz wrote:Wondering why they don't let the spouses of Irish citizens take the EU line as well? Although even if they did, there no doubt would be endless hassle.
Maybe it's because they can't tell Irish spouses from any other stamp 4 holder?
shoulda, coulda, woulda .. We tried using the EU line and when we got to the top of it were told to go to the back of the non-EU line by a very grumpy Officer. Won't be trying that againDirective/2004/38/EC wrote:Hmmm Well.... What happens if you are Irish and coming from working in another EU country with your spouse.... Then European law applies (Singh case). So those spouses of Irish people should be able to use the EU line. ....esharknz wrote:Wondering why they don't let the spouses of Irish citizens take the EU line as well? Although even if they did, there no doubt would be endless hassle.
Maybe it's because they can't tell Irish spouses from any other stamp 4 holder?
It will ultimately work, but i will estimate the Irish spouse and the wife to be at the Airport for at least 3 hours. The department of Justice sent back my Irish friend's application after her filed an application for his wife he was living with in the UK.esharknz wrote: Hmmm Well.... What happens if you are Irish and coming from working in another EU country with your spouse.... Then European law applies (Singh case). So those spouses of Irish people should be able to use the EU line. ....