My friend is away on holidays... My friend is very diligent in what he does, I'm sure he has supplied almost everything related. Of what i recall, he submitted, the employment contract, 12 months of payslips, bank statements, Ltd company details as well as explaining the structure/relationship. As previously mentioned, the caseworkers's response for rejection was that no tax return was supplied. He even appealed against the decision quoting from the application form & guidance note that no where does it state that tax returns are mandatory. But alas, appeal still rejected. Personally, i think he caught that caseworker on a bad day. I reckon it all comes down to luck! So good luck everyone... May you all get what you deserve!