lala2312 wrote:Hi Guys,
Just an update on the proceedings of my appeal. So as mentioned earlier my appeal was 2 days ago which was the 27th of April, I have just received the out ome of my appeal. It reads:
Considerations and findings
I have carefully considered the letter from the university which was submitted to the Respondent with the Appellant's application. The letter was dated 26 November 2009. Although the letter reffered to recommendation for the award, it clearly stated in the last sentence of the second paragraph that after 21 December the Appellant would be entitled to receive a certificate to confirm the award. The appeallant did receive the diploma on the 21 of December 2009. Therefore, I was satisfied that the appeallant was entitled to receive the points that she had claimed.
As regards the bank statements, the Appeallant did provide originals at the hearing which I compared with the copy statements in the bundle and the Respondent's bundle. The bank satements clearly showed that the appeallant had in excess of #800 from the 29 September 2009 until 31 December 2009, and beyond. I therefore find that the Appeallant was entitled to 10 points for maintenance.
On the evidence before me, I find that the appeallant has established on a balance of probabilities that she satisfied the requirements of the rules on the date of the Respondent's decision. Applying the law to the establish facts, I find that the Respondent's decision was not in accordance with the law and the applicable immigration rules. This appeal is allowed in respect of the immigration rules.
The Appeallant has not claimed that any rights protected under the 1950 convention have been breached. I am nevertheless required to consider whether the appealllant's claim engages any such rights. I find, on the facts as I have found them to be, that it does not.
DECISION.
The appeal is dismissed in respect of immigration rules.
Can anyone explain to me what they mean by this, please? Appeal allowed and appeal dismissed. Is this just an error?
Many thanks....
I think that there has been an error here. The appeal has clearly been accepted from whatever the judge has written. He has probably been dismissing a lot of appeals and out of habit has written the same on your form. Or maybe he just cant bring himself to accept that this appeal has been successful. I think that you should probably call the tribunal and inform them about this error or ask them what the final outcome is since this letter from the tribunal makes no sense.. Where was your appeal heard?
