- FAQ
- Login
- Register
- Call Workpermit.com for a paid service +44 (0)344-991-9222
ESC
Welcome to immigrationboards.com!
Moderators: Casa, Amber, archigabe, batleykhan, ca.funke, ChetanOjha, EUsmileWEallsmile, JAJ, John, Obie, push, geriatrix, vinny, CR001, zimba, meself2, Administrator
From my experience here in the forum as your file sent to the minister so you will get the approval.churchholigan wrote:Hi
Thank you for the quick reply. The lady actually said they are just preparing my file but has not send to the minister yet because they are waiting for more files from other applicant together before they send it over. So does it mean that I can still wait for another few months before they send my file over. Also, if they sending my file over for decision, does it mean that they could refuse me for whatever reason??
Thank you.
Every file has to be signed by minister regardless of its status whether its approved or disapproved.churchholigan wrote:Hi
Thank you for the quick reply. The lady actually said they are just preparing my file but has not send to the minister yet because they are waiting for more files from other applicant together before they send it over. So does it mean that I can still wait for another few months before they send my file over. Also, if they sending my file over for decision, does it mean that they could refuse me for whatever reason??
Thank you.
I believe you are wrong, those files that reach the Minister's table are the approved one for his signature, those that failed are treated and replied to by 3 different officers in the department with their names and signatures.myimmigrationboards wrote:Every file has to be signed by minister regardless of its status whether its approved or disapproved.churchholigan wrote:Hi
Thank you for the quick reply. The lady actually said they are just preparing my file but has not send to the minister yet because they are waiting for more files from other applicant together before they send it over. So does it mean that I can still wait for another few months before they send my file over. Also, if they sending my file over for decision, does it mean that they could refuse me for whatever reason??
Thank you.
you are not right. all files go to the minister with a recomendation as to be approved or refused. the minister then can agree or disgree. it's his decision.rlow68 wrote:I believe you are wrong, those files that reach the Minister's table are the approved one for his signature, those that failed are treated and replied to by 3 different officers in the department with their names and signatures.myimmigrationboards wrote:Every file has to be signed by minister regardless of its status whether its approved or disapproved.churchholigan wrote:Hi
Thank you for the quick reply. The lady actually said they are just preparing my file but has not send to the minister yet because they are waiting for more files from other applicant together before they send it over. So does it mean that I can still wait for another few months before they send my file over. Also, if they sending my file over for decision, does it mean that they could refuse me for whatever reason??
Thank you.
The refusals are all by the staff unless it is a very special case that need the attention of the minister.
Rightly said, common good, and common aim, the minister will read everything before attesting his signature.agniukas wrote:you are not right. all files go to the minister with a recomendation as to be approved or refused. the minister then can agree or disgree. it's his decision.rlow68 wrote:I believe you are wrong, those files that reach the Minister's table are the approved one for his signature, those that failed are treated and replied to by 3 different officers in the department with their names and signatures.myimmigrationboards wrote:Every file has to be signed by minister regardless of its status whether its approved or disapproved.churchholigan wrote:Hi
Thank you for the quick reply. The lady actually said they are just preparing my file but has not send to the minister yet because they are waiting for more files from other applicant together before they send it over. So does it mean that I can still wait for another few months before they send my file over. Also, if they sending my file over for decision, does it mean that they could refuse me for whatever reason??
Thank you.
The refusals are all by the staff unless it is a very special case that need the attention of the minister.
if its the refusal, then the staff at citizenship section would write the letter to the applicant with the negative outcome. but the decision is always made by the minister. staff at INIS can only suggest, lets say, the person has traffic offences or something, and the minister may say, no that's not that serious, i grant the person.
It's legitimate and fundamental to renew your residency permit pending the determination of your naturalization certificate application, after it's granted you may or may not need to renew any residency again at your discretion, i think that will suffice for your question, and i wish you all the best.Diago1234567 wrote:Hi guys I have been told since 01/07/2011 that my file has been sent to the minister for decision and I rang them a few times the answer was the same they still waiting for minister decision.
Last call to the INIS I asked the lady about my visa expiry date which was 09/08/11 what should I do. She asked me to go to the gnib and ask them for 1 month extension on my passport cos no need to renew it for the all year to avoid paying 150 euro for gnib card.
What do u think guys ???
I spoke to INIS on the helpline yesterday. I don't know if the lady on the phone told me the truth or not but she said do not phone back for another 4 weeks as my application is in the final stage. Hopefully it is going to be good news instead of rejection letter but thank you for the advance:)IQU wrote:congrats it will be within 4-6 weeks.good luck make sure dont forget to check your post lol![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
churchholigan wrote:I spoke to INIS on the helpline yesterday. I don't know if the lady on the phone told me the truth or not but she said do not phone back for another 4 weeks as my application is in the final stage. Hopefully it is going to be good news instead of rejection letter but thank you for the advance:)IQU wrote:congrats it will be within 4-6 weeks.good luck make sure dont forget to check your post lol![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
I am sorry to disappoint you but its basically a fob off letter. This kind of reply is usually what minister give to the deputies in the Dail. See below:irishtobe wrote:hi all
i get this leeter from the inis anybody have any idea if that good news?.
MR xxxxx lodged a valid application for a certificate of naturalisation
with the Citizenship Division of this Department on the 28th April 2008.
This application is currently being processed with a view to establishing
whether Mr. xxxxx meets the statutory conditions for the granting of
naturalisation and will be submitted to the Minister for decision as
expeditiously as possible.
The granting of Irish citizenship through naturalisation is a privilege and
an honour which confers certain rights and entitlements not only within the
State but also at European Union level and it is important that appropriate
procedures are in place to preserve the integrity of the process.
Mr. xxxxx :i will be notified of the decision, in writing, as soon as it
![]()
[/code]irishtobe wrote:hi all
i get this leeter from the inis anybody have any idea if that good news?.
MR xxxxx lodged a valid application for a certificate of naturalisation
with the Citizenship Division of this Department on the 28th April 2008.
This application is currently being processed with a view to establishing
whether Mr. xxxxx meets the statutory conditions for the granting of
naturalisation and will be submitted to the Minister for decision as
expeditiously as possible.
The granting of Irish citizenship through naturalisation is a privilege and
an honour which confers certain rights and entitlements not only within the
State but also at European Union level and it is important that appropriate
procedures are in place to preserve the integrity of the process.
Mr. xxxxx :i will be notified of the decision, in writing, as soon as it
This letter is simple because your TD contacted them on your behalf period.[/list]
I think all this callings and panicking displayed is actually giving them the ego to continue to delay approval of citizenship, as if it's a passport to paradise unlike the ways other european countries treated applicant despite warning from the european union on Irish government attitude towards applications of naturalizations among the European archipelag.IRISH PHAROE wrote:"After she told me that Minister could take as much as he needs to make a decision. Does it sound like I am in trouble or something?"
no no do not worry my friend the minister can take something in between 2 weeks to 2 months.
in my case I sent them my documents on early May upon their request and have been told that my file with the minister on end of May then I got my approval by Mid of June.