Post
by Jeff Albright » Wed Jun 27, 2007 11:38 am
Perhaps they are - I must admit I am not familiar with this type of situation, never experienced it. This was over top of my head.
However, it is still up to the person to sign or not to sign. If you sign, you agree, if you don't - you don't - it is still up to you.
Technically, they cannot prevent her from leaving or detain her for not answering questions or having no documents. They have powers under the Immigration Rules and they question and assess passengers on arrival, i.e. whether they qualify for entry under the Immigration Rules. The Rules have no effect on leaving passengers, not as far as things stand at the moment. Therefore, speaking in terms of the relevant law, they have no power to force her to sign anything or make her answer their questions. She may simply say "no comment" and that's all.
It is always advisable to cooperate in such situations and behave reasonably to avoid problems in the future. However, it is still up to the person - it is their decision.
Also, the criminal offences for not producing passport on request, etc. only apply to inward passengers traffic.
We can only see how she goes...