Post
by Abc499 » Sun May 15, 2016 10:56 am
(with my little knowledge and from my understanding)
In the HO letter:
"In your application made on 11/2013 you claimed £38000 self-employed earnings for the period of 11/2012 to 10/2013 from self-employment limited company. The SA 302 for 2012,2013,and 2014 submitted and our records show that you claimed earnings for self-employment to HMRC as £ 1320, £ 8300 and £ 8000 for tax years 2011/2012, 2012/13 and 2013/14. (Please note that for my extension I had provided 2 sources of earnings salary+dividends, £7000+£31000 which were spreaded over 2 self-assessments 2012/13 and 2013/14. Above mentioned figures by case worker are not from self-employment rather they are from employment as a director and there were dividends of £31000 in provided SA302 below my employment income which were been ignored). "
#what I understand that SA302 usually include all the incomes (salaried, self employment all), its the return that we submit and on the return we need to add all our incomes salaried, self-employed all incomes. So if your provided SA302 says £ 1320, £ 8300 and £ 8000 for three years then it is very much possible that case worker can think this is all you income during this period. what you are thinking that self-assessment income is on top of SA302 and generally case worker should think that way! probably it is not.
#(THEY DID NOT ADDED MY DIVIDEND EARNINGS WHICH WERE PART OF MY PREVIOUS EXTENSION AND REFLECTING IN SA302 TOO)- is that your accountant SA302 calculation ??? or HMRC SA302?
# what I think may be you have corrected the self-employed income and update it to HMRC but SA302 remain same as the for later update they are not updating the SA302.
# In general we try to show that we are correct and we are right but if we try to show it here then it will not help on our visa and we need to show that to case worker. you did not mention clearly 11/2013 claim of 38K what was before and what was after amendment and what is the HMRC document for this which shows this income (I know its between two year but what is the HMRC document shows this)
# I believe here everyone discuss and try to help others voluntarily if they can so please don't be angry its not always we know everything, if you could mention more clearly what is the document you provide against the 38K then it will be much better for everyone to help that how effective the claim could be establish.
# Why AR is mostly negative are the case worker error free?- I think AR is not something they reconsider the full application its most likely they simply see on the ground a case worker refuse the application, case worker ground valid or not. yes if we paid the tax and have strong ground then probably we will get positive decision in JR. Even case worker can refuse an application if it seems to them that this income does not look genuine (even though tax paid)
(I'am applying end of this month. I amend 2011 return in 2013 but SA302 HMRC will not update, so Im scared that they will tell me the same. I will add the revised tax calculation with application)
